This is not the entry I had originally intended to write. My mother was 70 last weekend and P and I were hosts as the family gathered to celebrate. I had in mind a short but heart-warming piece about how much I love my Mum and what a fabulous time we had all had.
On Friday night, wine glass in hand, I asked my mother how she intended to spend her next decade. Her reply: “Preparing for the afterlife”.
In many families that would pass with a smile and chuckle. My mother, however, is serious. There is nothing wrong with the end - who wouldn’t prefer heaven to hell as a final destination? The problem is with the means that she has decided to adopt to get her past the pearly gates. Mum is a great believer in the sanctifying power of misery and victimhood. There being little real opportunity for misery she finds herself compelled to create a steady supply.
She turned from our conversation to provoking an argument with my brother-in-law; accusing him of drinking heavily every night. He pointed out that he only drinks on a Saturday evening and that is limited to three small bottles of beer. That could not be true, Mum countered, because every day she sees three empty bottles on the kitchen counter. They were, it seems, the same three bottles waiting patiently for the weekly recycle. This forced Mum to switch to accusations of slovenliness. Feeble though that allegation was it proved to be enough to prompt my brother-in-law wearily to move away from the table.
“Oh dear” said my mother “have I said the wrong thing again? I am always in trouble”. We all went off to bed with the smell of martyred flesh hanging in the air.
The next morning it was time to spring the big surprise. P and I have a photograph of three generations of her family clowning about which my mother has long coveted. She likes to stand in front of it and sigh, observing that our family could never be persuaded to gather for a “nice photo” even though we all know how much she would like one. In preparation for Mum’s birthday, my sister H contacted a professional photographer, checked his portfolio and then arranged for him to travel 250 miles to take the definitive Moobs family portrait. P and my other sister C were deputed to tell my mother what was happening so that she would have plenty of time to gussy herself up.
I arrived on the scene to find C in tears, P eyeing my mother murderously and my mother striking a pose like St Catherine on a mass card. “It’s not what I want” my Mother was saying “It’s all too much trouble. I just want each of you to give me a nice little photo I can put on the wall next to each other”. “Too much trouble” is a trope my mother resorts to a lot. No-one in the world is as skilled as my mother as using a supposed desire to avoid trouble to create so much of it.
C was heart-broken and left the room crying. Mum found her and stooping to comfort told her “I don’t see why I should be made to feel guilty for not wanting something”. To which C replied “I don’t see why I should be made to feel guilty for trying to make you happy”. C, bless her, misses the point, being unhappy is what makes my mother happy.
Being the eldest, I have a few more years of mother-wrangling experience and knew that the best thing was to fight passive aggression with passive aggression and told her that it was no problem and that I would immediately phone the photographer and tell him that when his train completed its three hour journey into London he should turn right round and go home. It would be, I suggested, no trouble. Mum demurred.
P had to take her to buy shoes for the photo shoot. My mother informed the shop assistant that she would probably give the shoes away to charity the following week as she only buying them because she had been forced to. P simmered.
Over the next few hours we were treated to the following:
- The grandchildren being waved away in the middle of an attempt to present Mum with a card and chocolates with the words “Oh don’t bother about that now”;
- Her reaction to being presented with $60 worth of cut fresh flowers bought by her siblings: “Oh, Ok”;
- Her informing us that she thought her siblings gathering to sing her happy birthday over a Skype connection was “a lot of ridiculous fuss”.
Once the photos were taken we got her round the corner to our local restaurant and kept her wine glass filled. She immediately cheered up. It was such a joy to see her laughing and the relief was palpable. Once home again, she even joined in throwing a frisbee about the garden.
It was not to last. By 8:00pm, she insisted that I cancel the breakfast at the Dorchester Hotel we had booked for her, again on the basis that being carried by taxi to a luxury hotel and eating a breakfast produced by a kitchen run by one of Europe’s star chefs, was “a lot of trouble and inconvenience”.
The weird thing is that whilst we may have spent the weekend chewing our tongues and tearing at our hair, I think she enjoyed herself. Happy Birthday Mum.